The leadership tussle within the Fountain of Life Church has continued with the Board of Trustees insisting on the removal of Pastor Jimmy Odukoya as the Senior Pastor of the church.
The trustees also announced the interim spiritual and administrative leadership of the Church be entrusted to the Pastor Rotimi Okpaise. This was disclosed in a fresh statement on Tuesday, insisting that their resolution of November 16 withdrawing recognition of Odukoya remained in force.
Odukoya had rejected the trustees’ earlier announcement of his removal, insisting that he remains the church’s duly recognised Senior Pastor. The trustees had cited governance concerns and a December 2021 video in which the late founder, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya, reportedly named a different preferred successor. However, Odukoya rejected his removal as unconstitutional, arguing that the trustees behind the announcement had been asked to resign in March 2026.
But in the latest statement, the trustees stood by their decision and provided further details about the video, alleging that Jimmy Odukoya failed to disclose the existence of the video when his appointment was being considered.
According to the trustees, the late founder had asked to record a video identifying his preferred successor. They said the person named was not Jimmy and alleged that the recording was not presented to them until late December 2025, more than two years after Taiwo Odukoya’s death.
It said it had relied on Jimmy’s account that his late father had handed over the mantle of leadership to him when considering his appointment as Senior Pastor. The trustees described the non-disclosure of the recording as a significant development, arguing that it could have influenced their deliberations.
“The Board considers this omission particularly grave, as the disclosure of such information could reasonably have influenced its deliberations and the ultimate decision reached,” the statement read.
The board added that it had completed its review of the recording, the circumstances surrounding Jimmy’s appointment and the implications for the church’s succession process.
It said the issue was not merely about the identity of the person appointed but whether the decision was reached with full and transparent disclosure of relevant information.
“The fundamental issue, therefore, is not simply the identity of the person appointed, but whether the Board’s decision was reached on the basis of full, accurate and transparent disclosure of all material information relevant to the succession process,” it stated.
The trustees said the present controversy was “not an isolated incident,” disclosing that they had spent several months trying to resolve concerns about leadership succession, church administration and adherence to established governance arrangements.
According to the board, it had preferred dialogue, reconciliation and peaceful resolution over public confrontation. It also said it sought the intervention of respected Christian leaders whom the church’s founding pastors held in high esteem.
However, the trustees alleged that their efforts had not produced the desired outcome, accusing Jimmy of failing to provide the cooperation required to resolve the disagreements.
“Pastor Jimmy Odukoya has not provided the level of engagement and cooperation necessary to achieve a satisfactory resolution,” the statement read.
The board further cited what it described as unresolved governance concerns, alongside moral and doctrinal controversies, as reasons for its intervention.
It said it could not remain indifferent while the church’s spiritual heritage, institutional integrity and public reputation faced what it described as continuing erosion.
“The responsibility of the Board is therefore not merely administrative or custodial. It is also a solemn obligation to preserve the integrity of the Church, safeguard its doctrine and protect the spiritual welfare of its congregation,” it stated.