The Court of Appeal in Kaduna has set aside a previous Federal High Court judgment in a human rights suit filed by former Kaduna State Governor, Nasir El-Rufai, and ordered a fresh hearing before a different judge.
The unanimous ruling by a three-judge panel – Justices Onyekachi Otisi, Abimbola Obaseki-Adejumo, and Sybil Gbagi found that the lower court violated El-Rufai’s constitutional right to a fair hearing. The court declared the July 30, 2024, judgment null and void.
The case stems from an investigation by the Kaduna State House of Assembly into the state government’s finances, loans, and contracts between May 2015 and May 2023. The committee had accused El-Rufai of misappropriating N400bn. El-Rufai argued that he was not formally notified to appear before the committee, even though about 70 others were invited, and the panel proceeded to make recommendations affecting him.
The appellate court noted that there was no credible proof El-Rufai received notice of the hearings. A text message sent to his lawyer was rejected as evidence due to inconsistencies in the phone numbers, and oral statements from a court registrar were deemed legally inadequate.
Justice Otisi emphasized that proper service of hearing notices is essential for a court to have jurisdiction. “Failure to serve court notice denied the appellant the opportunity to respond and participate, which is fundamental to the right to a fair trial,” he said.
The panel stressed that while courts should resolve cases quickly, constitutional rights cannot be ignored. The appellate court ordered that the case be reheard from the beginning by another judge, with all parties bearing their own costs.
Justices Obaseki-Adejumo and Gbagi supported the lead judgment, underlining the importance of ensuring that parties receive proper notice before proceedings.