Foreign investors in the agriculture sector are considering bringing claims against the U.S. government, arguing that new tariffs may violate international investment treaties that guarantee fair treatment and protection of investments.
According to Fortune, international agribusinesses with U.S. subsidiaries and distribution networks have been hit hard by tariffs on produce such as bananas, blueberries, avocados, and coffee—imports worth more than $33 billion in 2023. These measures have forced companies to renegotiate contracts, shift operations, and in some cases, face being priced out of the U.S. market.
“Fresh produce has had no tariffs since the 1990s,” said Tiffany Comprés, co-chair of international disputes at Pierson Ferdinand LLP, who represents foreign agriculture investors. “It’s already a low-margin business. Imposing tariffs destroys the ability of these businesses to function.”
If investors proceed, they could bring cases to international arbitration tribunals, rather than U.S. courts, under treaties such as CAFTA-DR or Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs). These agreements include protections like “fair and equitable treatment” and bar measures that deprive investors of the benefits of their investments.
Some Latin American exporters, such as Guatemala and Honduras, may have grounds for claims under CAFTA-DR. Meanwhile, producers in countries like Brazil, which faces tariffs as high as 50% on coffee exports, lack treaty protection.
Still, experts caution that such claims face steep challenges. The U.S. has never lost an investor-state dispute, said Robert Howse, professor of international law at NYU. Investors would need to prove that their U.S.-based assets—such as warehouses, machinery, or distribution networks—were rendered effectively worthless by tariffs. Even then, Washington could argue that tariff policy falls within its sovereign right to regulate trade.
Comprés noted that many investors are waiting for the Supreme Court’s ruling on the legality of tariffs before moving forward. With some treaties allowing up to five years to file claims, she expects actions could emerge within that timeframe.
“I would be shocked if we didn’t start to see claims within the next five years,” she said.